With college football just around the corner — less than one month away! — I figured now would be a good time to piss off a lot of people by unveiling my ultimate 11. This is sort of a preseason All-American list, but it is my list, so I expect to get hammered in the comments section due to leaving off your favorite player. Yes, there are several great players at each position, but only one can make it. This means I will undoubtedly leave someone off who may deserve a spot on the list. For this I’m sorry (honestly, I’m not sorry, but I figured I’d give you a weak apology to ease your anger). The numbers mentioned indicate the players’ stats from last season, not projections for the upcoming year. Here is you’re Ultimate 11 on defense (we did the Ultimate 11 on offense yesterday). Let the bitch-fest commence!
Jerry Hughes, DE, TCU: Hughes has been a stud for TCU for the past few years and he looks to have one more sack-filled season before he opts for the NFL. While many people know next-to-nothing about TCU, the college football nuts know that this is one of the premier Non-BCS schools alongside Utah and Boise State. The Horned Frogs have gone 30-9 over the past three seasons, and almost all of that success has been due to a stout defense. Hughes is the statistical leader of the TCU defense, finishing last season with 52 tackles, 15 sacks, one forced fumble, two interceptions and one touchdown. The guy is a freak. Though he is small for a defensive end (6-2), he is quick and has some serious strength.
Ndamukong Suh, DT, Nebraska: Not as many people know about Suh as they should. Last season Suh was the best defensive tackle in the country, but because Nebraska has been all-but-forgotten in the national media (losing a lot will do that), he went relatively unnoticed. That won’t be the case this year. Nebraska has four nationally televised games and Suh will be the anchor of a Bo Pelini defense. Last season Suh tallied 76 tackles, seven sacks, two interceptions and two touchdowns (one of them on offense). The guy is a total beast and will most likely be a top-1o pick in the 2010 NFL draft. Here is a 2 minute video of Suh whopping that ass.
Gerald McCoy, DT, Oklahoma: McCoy is a beast, like Suh, but his stats don’t tell all of the story. He finished last season with 26 tackles, six sacks and one interception, but he did so while facing double and triple teams weekly. McCoy is a huge dude, standing 6-4 and weighing just a shade under three bills, so his body can take the pounding that the NFL will demand. While I think he is not quite the player Suh is, he is still a dominant force.
Carlos Dunlap, DE, Florida: Dunlap is an interesting cat. He stands 6-6 and weighs 290 pounds, but he looks quicker than he is strong. He plays like a pure speed rusher, but the man is gigantic, which makes him scary as hell to offensive lineman. Last season he finished with 36 tackles and nine sacks. Before Florida defensive tackle Torrey Davis left the Florida team, Dunlap looked like he was a lock for single coverage most of the year. Now that the big man in the middle is gone, Dunlap can once again deal with double teams early and often. I still like him to get to 10 sacks this season, and then bolt due to a top-10 draft grade.
Greg Jones, LB, Michigan State: The Spartans have always seemed to be one great player short of making a run at the Big 10. They might have a good offense, but the defense falls short. They might have a great running game, but their quarterback falls short. This year the Spartans are said to be a defensive team first. This is not a real surprise as head coach Mark Dantonio comes from a defensive background. The Spartans are led by preseason defensive player of the year winner Greg Jones. Jones is a man-child for Sparty. Any time you are recognized as the best linebacker in the Big 10, you know you’re good. While Jones’s sack numbers are low (six in the past two years as a starter), his tackle numbers are insane. Last year he finished with 127 tackles (80 solo). This year he will be the face of the Spartans and should make his presence well known.
Brandon Spikes, LB, Florida: One of the most ridiculous stats entering the 2009 season is that the defending national champion Gators return all 11 starters from last year’s defense. I don’t remember ever hearing about a team winning a title and returning all starters on any side of the ball. The Gators defense will be led by middle linebacker Brandon Spikes. As a sophomore Spikes led the Gators in tackles with 131, but last year, with a much-improved defense, his tackles dipped considerably (87), but he added four interceptions and two touchdowns. Spikes turned down the NFL (rumors were he did not get a first round grade) and will now look to make it three national championships in four seasons for the Gators. He can be seen here almost killing Knowshon Moreno.
Travis Lewis, LB, Oklahoma: This is one of the defensive choices that will probably enlist a harsh response. Lewis started for the Sooners last year after their initial starter went down to injury. As a true freshman, Lewis finished with 135 tackles, three sacks, one forced fumble and four picks…as a true freshman playing in a league where offenses dominate. This year Lewis will be a stud for the Sooners and should help Oklahoma bring the pain on that side of the ball. With McCoy eating up offensive lineman, look for Lewis to be able to attack the quarterback more often than last year and make a name for himself nationally.
Trevard Lindley, CB, Kentucky: Lindley might be the most unknown member of my Ultimate 11, but the dude can play. Sadly for him, he plays for Kentucky so no one cares what he does. His a legit lock-down corner, so he gets few balls thrown his way. Last season he ended with four picks and one touchdown to go along with 38 tackles. While he is a relative unknown, the dude can play and just may be a first round pick when he opts for the big leagues.
Ahmad Black, CB, Florida: Black might not be as well known as fellow Gator defensive backs Joe Haden or Major Wright, but the dude is a baller of the highest order. As a sophomore he finished with 54 tackles, seven picks (for 191 return yards) and two touchdowns. Black is just one of the reasons why Florida will have the nastiest secondary in college football next year. He has speed, quickness and all of the confidence to be a top flight corner. While he is on the small side (5-9), he makes up for it by being a total badass.
Eric Berry, SS, Tennessee: You know what is depressing? Having a man-crush on one of your rivals’ star players. Berry was the one lock for this list for me. Dude is a machine. Last year he finished with 72 tackles, three sacks and seven picks. He has averaged, in just two years, 243.5 yards in interception returns. He is just 15 yards shy of breaking Terrell Buckley’s record, which he will most likely do in the first game. Now that he has the best defensive mind in football coaching him in Monte Kiffin, the sky isn’t even the limit for Berry this year. While Tebow and Bradford gets all of the love in the national media, Berry is my pick as the best player in all of college football. Here you can watch Berry dominate.
Taylor Mays, FS, Southern California: Mays is somewhat of an enigma. He has the size (6-3, 230) and speed (electronic sub 4.4 forty) to dominate as a free safety, yet his numbers aren’t what they should be. He had just 53 tackles last year and had a grand total of zero sacks and interceptions. However, his lack of numbers may have been due to the fact that his USC defense was unstoppable last year and by the time the ball reached Mays’s spot in the secondary the play was over. Mays shocked the college football world when he opted to stay at USC for one more year, but he stayed to be the team leader on defense and this year look for Mays to share the defensive limelight with Eric Berry.
Popularity: 7% [?]
Posted in Uncategorized
















Navarro Bowman and Sean Lee will show themselves to be better than Greg Jones
(Quote)
mccoy, dunlap and lewis are the only three i have any real beef with, but don’t really disagree with you.
dunlap is all potential right now and, from what i’ve seen, is moving inside to play more DT, but he’s got scary potential. sergio kindle would’ve been a solid choice here.
mccoy is great, but terrence cody is more dominant in the middle.
lewis? meh. kind of a weak LB crop to choose from tho.
(Quote)
good call…navorro bowman should be on there instead of lewis. forgot about him.
(Quote)
funny stuff. really funny. jones can do it all by himself. they need each other.
(Quote)
Funny Bowman didn’t need Lee last year
(Quote)
no, but he had maybin and others. jones hasn’t had the talent around him like penn states has.
(Quote)
Lewis is going to be a stud…plain and simple. Of course this sucks because he was all set to go to Nebraska and then backed out a week before signing day. Kindle was my original choice, but I went Dunlap for some reason. Kindle is a beast, but I wonder if he will hold up against the run. I also thought about putting Morgan Burnett over Mays, but the upside (Mel Kiper word of the century) is higher for Mays.
(Quote)
I will be curious to see if McCoy gets the pub this year over Suh. Last year the B12 coaches chose him over Suh as the best DT yet the numbers weren’t even in the same stratosphere.
(Quote)
weren’t like half of kindle’s tackles TFL’s? he’ll be ok against the run…partly because he was pretty good against beanie wells in the fiesta bowl and partly because the only team that runs in the big XII is Okie State.
(Quote)
I think Cody is not as good as many think. He is great against teams that line up and run at him, but is a spread teams plays Bama the dude is a bound to have a heart attack. If i played Bama I would run a no huddle 3 plays in a row and then run it again, but hold the line for 20 seconds and make him play in his stance. I’d run 20 pounds off of him by the end of the game.
(Quote)
100% totally agree. lard ass!!!
(Quote)
You’re right. If he were in a dif league he may have to deal with bruising backs, but in the B12 there simply isn’t a team that doesn’t run some form of the spread.
(Quote)
the problem with that, tho, is who really wants to throw against THAT secondary? saban knows DB’s, and these DB’s are all ridiculous talents, and even without a pass rush worth a shit, bama was solid against the pass. much easier said than done.
and even then…cody still eats up two blockers every play…the 4 LB’s would be able to go blitz crazy.
(Quote)
Don’t get me wrong, he is a very good DT, but I think he is not as good as McCoy or Suh. He’ll make his money in the NFl b/c DT is one of the hardest positions to find, but I like Suh much better in the NFL.
(Quote)
and he will be as good as grady jackson. which isn’t terrible, but nothing great.
(Quote)
The blitz scheme Bama will run this year will be epic. I like Florida’s DB’ better, but I like Saban’s instincts as a defensive play caller better than anyone in college football.
(Quote)
seriously?
have you even seen grady jackson play? despite the massive gut, he’s nothing more than a quick, one-gap pass rushing DT. they look alike, but they play nothing alike.
cody is vince wilfork NOW. a pure 3-4 NT who’s immovable at the point. he’ll make his coin because there are less good 3-4 NT’s than there are good QB’s in the NFL.
(Quote)
Totally agree. He won’t be elite, but he will always have a job. I think a player to look out for is Rolando McClain from bama. I think he is going to be a breakout player this year and make a name for himself.
(Quote)
don’t see him at that point yet. possibly, but not yet.
(Quote)
im shocked at the mt. cody hate around here.
how many players get to be coached by an nfl-caliber 3-4 coach IN COLLEGE? i’ll save you from doing research…none.
but i love mcclain too. agree on that.
(Quote)
Dunlap is staying at the end.
(Quote)
Agreed on McClain…he’s gonna be scary good.
(Quote)
spencer, i always have doubt about gargantuan DTs and their prospects are being incredibly successful in the NFL. wilfork may have been a 1st round selection, but he was drafted at 21 by the pats coming off a super bowl win, and richard seymour lining up next to him. would wilfork have been just as successful had saban drafted him and started him for the Dolphins in the 3-4?
(Quote)
wait, i know, jason taylor next to him. but the pats had depth behind him LB too.
(Quote)
Good question who was the last GIANT Dt to get drafted to a shit team and play well? Sapp?
(Quote)
sparty…good question. i really can’t answer that, but i will say that NE has the best 3-man front in the NFL by miles. ty warren doesn’t get enough credit.
as long as cody doesn’t get drafted by the 49ers or browns, he should be fine. he’ll probably get drafted in the teens, and i wouldn’t be surprised to see PIT or Dallas move up to get him. he’d be casey hampton’s perfect replacement.
(Quote)
sapp was never giant…always played around 300.
john henderson and marcus stroud were drafted by the jags when they sucked. haynesworth comes to mind even tho he took awhile to get going. shaun rogers has had a nice career for some shitty teams.
(Quote)
So what you’re saying is that Michigan State isn’t very good. I can agree with that
(Quote)
they were an avg team last year. yes.
(Quote)
Not hating on Cody, I’m just not sold on him, that’s all.
(Quote)
He was a bigger DT for his height than most guys.
(Quote)
DT’s are just tough to gauge. spencer has a point about them being in the right situation, like wilfork going to a 3-4. cody can’t go to a team that plays a 4-3. i think chris canty had been forced to play DE in dallas in a 3-4, now he gets to play DE and DT in a 4-3. i think he will be much better because of it. when sapp moved to the outside in Oakland, he struggled.
(Quote)
I hate Cody…there I said it.
(Quote)
Struggled is a nice way to say it.
(Quote)
truth. there are very few can’t miss DT’s because there’s just so many questions with durability and work ethic.
(Quote)
Another player that I am very intrested in watching is Everson Griffin from USC. Dude is supposed to be a total freak, and with USC losing a lot on defense it would stand to reason that he would be a big part of their defense this year.
(Quote)
well, part of it was oakland just being the ultimate of suckitude.
(Quote)
i thought last year he’d kill everyone…never happened. really strange.
considering some of the clips i saw of him in practice, i thought he’d be a force.
(Quote)
pryor will get to see a lot of him.
(Quote)
I remember hearing that he was a beast, but he has yet to do much of anything. Of course USC can just line up another 5 star freak at DE in his place. Oh how the other half lives.
(Quote)
Gotta throw a small school in there Jay Ross of ECU is a pretty solid DT
(Quote)
Jerry Hughes too..from TCU
(Quote)
I feel bad for the rest of the B10 because Pryor is goin to own that league for the next two-three years. That dude is legit I think.
(Quote)
seriously…usc and florida have an embarassment of riches that even fans of other elite schools are jealous of.
(Quote)
Hughes is a stud. I wonder how he got away from the big schools in Texas (I assume that’s where he is from).
(Quote)
I know. Imagine being a Pac 10 fan outside of USC. At least the SEC has a few teams that can compete in terms of recruiting. USC is so much better than the rest of their own league. How they lose one BS game a year is beyond me.
(Quote)
he was a relatively unspectacular RB who converted to defense. i saw one of his HS games when i visited austin and he was a pretty good RB, but texas is full of guys like that.
plus, texas simply has too much talent to stock just texas and oklahoma. there’s always going to be players falling through the cracks.
(Quote)
You’re right about that. Texas is loaded with talent, and unlike Florida where there are so many football powers to compete with, Texas has only to deal with OU and LSU, but LSU pretty much stays in Louisiana because they have top-10 classes with out leaving the state.
(Quote)
it’s really inexcusable how they aren’t in the NC every year. it’s ridiculous how oregon and cal can get some scraps, but USC just kills every other school in the conference. the big 10 and big XII aren’t even that lopsided.
(Quote)
George Selvie situation. Was a high school runnning back who got accolades, just a big recruit high outta high school. Switched when he got to TCU.
(Quote)
The team loses focus so easy…plain and simple.
(Quote)
i am happy we don;t play him.
(Quote)
it’s ok…he burned MSU more than enough the first go around.
(Quote)
I’m oddly not afraid of him
(Quote)
im assuming you’re a PSU fan…and you shouldn’t be after the ass kicking you skeetering appalachians put on the buckeyes last year.
(Quote)
He won’t beat USC this year though…
(Quote)
spencer knows this. but OSU will lose because of their defense. not the o.
(Quote)
God I hate to say this but I actually hope Ohio States beat USC this year. Just to get people off the Big Ten’s back for a week
(Quote)
you should say that because OSU is the only team not full of suck on PSU’s roster.
and yea, OSU will lose because our secondary is dogshit and USC may have one of the few OL’s in the country who can handle OSU’s front 7. i think it’s close tho…relative of course…like only losing by like 14 or something.
(Quote)
College football talk! I love it, Ill have to come around more often.
All I have to add to this is that Eric Berry is a talent for the ages. Ive been reading up on UT’s early practices and apparently the guy just gets better and better
(Quote)
How shocking a MSU homer puts a marginal first team all big ten guy as one of the BEST players in college football.
(Quote)
HuskerDawg went to MSU??
(Quote)
is that not where the “Husker” came from in his name? I’m really confused now.
(Quote)
blazers – welcome to our humble abode. there will be a plethora of CFB talk here and we’re ramping it up now.
re: Berry…everything he did was under Chavis’ system. I know Monte Kiffin is supposed to be a defensive genius, but in my effed up head, he has a lot to live up to. he inherits the best defensive player in the country and a D that was in the top 10 in the country last year despite being on the field for the majority of the games due to the inept offense ranked in the 100’s in the country. the Tennessee defense will have to be extraordinary in order to best last year’s and I just hope Berry can be his badass self in the system.
(Quote)
Well, Michigan State did perform the first documented genetic crossing to produce hybrid corn.
(Quote)
miz- more i think about it, i think the Tampa 2 will unleash Berry even more. Think about how crappy of a player John Lynch was at safety, but how well he played in that system.
(Quote)
I have a freaking man-crush on Berry. Dude went to the high scool where my Dad taught, and even though he went to Tennessee, he might be my favorite player in all of college football. He hits harder than any other safety and he can run a sub 4.4 forty. Monte is going to turn him into the best player in college football in my opinion.
(Quote)
Agreed. Berry is a once in a lifetime safety. If college football didn’t hand the Heisman to best stat-monger every year this guy would be the legit leader.
(Quote)
Agreed. The Heisman has, for me anyway, completely lost its luster. It seems to always be the best player on the best team (though Tebow def. deserved it when he won it on a 9-4 team). Defensive players who don’t return kicks and play WR at times simply don’t have a chance.
(Quote)